In actuality this is a combination of peddocks island the decaying brick buildings, maines acadia national park, massachusetts medfield state hospital, and turner hill country clubs rice estate located in ipswich, ma, which were combined via cgi. The problem was that when they started shooting the film, they realized that upon first viewing the. The two continue to alcatraz island where things from the old civilization are preserved. Teddy wakes up to the reality that he is actually andrew laeddis, though he is warned by dr.
The problem was that when they started shooting the film, they realized that upon first viewing the audience would have to believe that dr. In an interview by a hollywood critic the day the film aired in the theatres, he asked that no one speak of it. Multiple murderess rachel solando is loose somewhere on this remote and barren island. Lehane is a master at creating palpable tension between the covers of a book, and nowhere is that more evident than in shutter island. What i mean is that in the book it is referenced that teddy had arrived in september 1954, yet later on in the book and as well as the movie they reference that. Compare and contrast shutter island book from movie. Along with his partner, chuck aule, he sets out to find an escaped patient, a murderess named rachel solando, as a hurricane bears down upon them.
A masterwork of suspense and surprise from the author of mystic river and gone, baby, gone, shutter island carries the reader into a nightmare world of madness, mind control, and cia cold war paranoia and is. The inception ending dominated movie headlines in 2010, but shutter island opened months earlier and had a similar last moment that continues to perplex. Unlike the book, the movie is comprised of multiple plausible plots that could all plausibly explain the same general story as well as the ending. This 59page guide for shutter island by dennis lehane includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis covering 25 chapters, as well as several more indepth sections of expertwritten literary analysis. The jury is still out on shutter islands correct interpretation, and the debate surrounding the films ending still rages today. The basis for the blockbuster motion picture directed by martin scorsese and starring leonardo dicaprio, shutter island by new york times bestselling author dennis lehane is a gripping and atmospheric psychological thriller where nothing is quite what it seems. The book denis lehanes shutter island fuses several different genres into a single work. Shutter island ending its really open for interpretation by the reader.
The director martin scorsese and the writer laeta kalogridis base the film on dennis lehanes 2003 bestselling novel. Not a single critique i can make about this wonderfully crafted, mind bending thrill ride of a movie lovers dream come true. K, so teddy is actually the guy hes been chasing his entire life, since his wife died. The story revolves around eli, a nomad in a postapocalyptic world, who is told by a voice to deliver his copy of a mysterious book to a safe location on the west coast of. Shutter island by dennis lehane 152,658 ratings, 4. During that era, severe mental disturbances were often dealt with physically. And sometimes, you see a movie that is so aggressively, stupidly did that youre just like, fuck me, that is. Shutter island is a contemporary motion picture version of a stylish hollywood crime drama. Lehane takes a departure form his regular series and takes us to shutter island.
Shutter islands ending explained david cox film the. The book of eli is a 2010 american postapocalyptic neo western action film directed by the hughes brothers, written by gary whitta, and starring denzel washington, gary oldman, mila kunis, ray stevenson, and jennifer beals. The meaning behind that question continues to spark debates. I was fortunate enough to attend the press junket for shutter island back when the movie was released, and had a chance to sit down with dicaprio, sir ben kingsley and martin scorsese. Jul 20, 2018 investigating the many twists and mysterious of the noir horror film shutter island starring leonardo dicaprio and directed by martin scorsese.
My belief is that teddyandrew had a second breakthrough and then relapsed again and was unable to accept the truth about himself, his wife, and their children. Jun 16, 2010 the ending of shutter island seems ambiguous to many people, but again, to me it was pretty clearcut. Shutter island, the latest film from academy award winning director martin scorsese. A visual analysis and explanation of the ending after eight handwritten pages of notes taken over two viewings aside from the first recreational viewing, i have only more questions and not enough answers as to the truth of shutter island. Marshal teddy daniels leonardo dicaprio, who along with his new partner, chuck aule mark ruffalo, are investigating the implausible escape of a patient from bostons shutter island ashecliffe hospital, an insane asylum located on a remote, windswept island. With leonardo dicaprio, emily mortimer, mark ruffalo, ben kingsley. After a shootout at a house in the middle of nowhere, solara and the book are captured and eli is wounded. And at its heart, shutter island seems to be peering into the nature of the human psyche.
Which is absolutely necessary to understanding the forthcoming deconstruction of the story in order to expose its inherent story architecture. Feb 20, 2010 i read the book and i saw the movie, and it does f with your head. Spoiler alert the following spills the beans about shutter island. Spoiler alert the following spills the beans about shutter island dont say you werent warned. Oct 12, 2017 the jury is still out on shutter island s correct interpretation, and the debate surrounding the films ending still rages today. Towards the end of the book maybe 23 or 34 of the way through, maybe someone with a better memory can help me out with the exact moment we find out that teddy is. In america, more than 40,000 patients were lobotomised over a 30year period. Eli bumps the bottom step with his foot before going up the porch steps of the couples house, presumably to gauge where the steps are credit to jeremyogles. Apr 15, 2003 dennis lehane, shutter island shutter island is one of the best films i have ever had the pleasure of seeing and i saw the film way before i ever read the book. Ill explain it to you, so you can appreciate the book because its definitely one of my favorites.
Shutter island summary and study guide supersummary. The locations for the film, based on the novel by dennis lehane, were in. Dennis lehane, shutter island shutter island is one of the best films i have ever had the pleasure of seeing and i saw the film way before i ever read the book. I just finished the book and am trying to get some insight on it, also. Sheehan that he has regressed into his fantasy world before. Mar 01, 2010 the book denis lehanes shutter island fuses several different genres into a single work.
Leonardo dicaprios previous film, martin scorseses shutter island, confused just as many cinemagoers. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading shutter island. Shutter island author dennis lehane gives his read on the. Dennis lehane booklist dennis lehane message board. In shutter island, what should be nourishing is notand what appears to be reality is not, either. The washington post raves, brilliantly conceived and executed. Might as well get that out of the way from the outset.
Knowing this will completely change your experience in seeing the film or reading the book. The character has the same name in both the book and the movie. Shutter island author dennis lehane gives his read on. Compare and contrast shutter island book from movie free. Hardboiled detective fiction meets a paranoid, cold war suspense thriller with late 60s scifi thrown in for good measure. On top of a powerful story line with a deep cast and a feel for how society dealt with mental illness during the early eisenhower red scare era, the climax is as good as a novel gets. According to the first plot, teddy daniels leonardo decaprio is an honest us marshall who is sent by the authorities to investigate the possibility of illegal experiments at the island hospital. I viewed the film through the lens of already knowing the plot twist, which made it a whole different experience. Shutter island is a wild ride, an impressive mystery, and an intense psychological thriller. Eli leaves and kills a bunch of carnegies men in a shoot out.
Which is absolutely necessary to understanding the forthcoming deconstruction continue reading. Psychological mystery thriller directed by martin scorsese. This is a book that stretched both the author and the reader. This is one of those cases where the book and the film are equal to each other. Spoilers every clue in the book of eli that explains the. Lehane called his book, homage to gothic, but also homage to b movies and pulp. Shutter island is a novel by american writer dennis lehane, published by harper collins in april 2003. This film ends with a massive plot twist that has resulted in debates on what happens in the last scene. Expect a more inyourface warning immediately preceding the major shutter island spoiler after the jump. A detailed plot analysis and explanation of the ending of the film shutter island what was in the lighthouse. Hes convinced the guys the killer, when actually the guy doesnt exist. Although both the movie and the book contain the same storyline, there are.
The stars and director talked at great length about how difficult it was to film shutter island. Learn all about the complicated story, hidden clues. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Marshal investigates the disappearance of a murderer who escaped from a hospital for the criminally insane. The new york times calls shutter island, startlingly original. Plot analysis shutter island is a brilliant film based on a book by the same name.
Dennis lehane is a talented writer, one who understands what readers want and expect in a suspense novel, and he gives it to them in overdose quantities. Jared potts katherine reeves film 17 august 2012 book vs. Old buildings and architecture were used to make the scene look realistic. During the ferry approach at the start, we are shown shutter island. Please be advised that this article gives away the ending of the movie. The ending of shutter island finally explained youtube. Marshals arrive on the island, now a hospital for the criminally insane, to investigate the disappearance of a patient.
Shutter island, the latest film from academy award winning director martin scorsese, is really best described as a long walk, or a 8 minute run time, for a short drink of water, or in shutters case, a simple and less than satisfying ending. Shutter island was one of the plot twisting endings to a movie ever in theaters. The book of eli is a 2010 american postapocalyptic neowestern action film directed by the hughes brothers, written by gary whitta, and starring denzel washington, gary oldman, mila kunis, ray stevenson, and jennifer beals. Feb 24, 2010 please be advised that this article gives away the ending of the movie. Sep 06, 2009 ill explain it to you, so you can appreciate the book because its definitely one of my favorites. Marshal teddy daniels and his new partner, chuck aule, have come to shutter island, home of ashecliffe hospital for the criminally insane, to investigate the disappearance of a patient. Martin scorsese wasnt kidding when he said that his neonoir psychological thriller shutter island would be twice as profitable because moviegoers would have to see it again just to understand. Mar 05, 2018 martin scorsese wasnt kidding when he said that his neonoir psychological thriller shutter island would be twice as profitable because moviegoers would have to see it again just to understand. Marshal teddy daniels has come to shutter island, home of ashecliffe hospital for the criminally insane. Marshall teddy, who is on shutter island with his partner chuck in order to investigate the disappearance one of the prisonerspatients from the mental asylum, meets the german psychiatrist dr. Investigating the many twists and mysterious of the noir horror film shutter island starring leonardo dicaprio and directed by martin scorsese.
Eli knows the couple eats people because of the rattling tea cups. Were here to correctly diagnose whats wrong amidst. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides for challenging works of literature. Cawley and shutter island could be something sinister, but upon second viewing you would have to be able to.
Sometimes di digital intermediate, that is, the computeraided manipulation of film to alter the color balance and saturation of the footage works pretty well. Keep in mind that this is just one mans theory, an interpretation of the events that transpired in the closing minutes of shutter island. Heres a spoilery explanation of what actually happened in the film. What i mean is that in the book it is referenced that teddy had arrived in september 1954, yet later on in the book and as well as the movie they reference that he was committed spring 1952, the. Lehane has said he sought to write a novel that would be a homage to gothic settings, b movies, and pulp. Contains spoilers almost every movie ever made was originally a book. Just looking at how many movies that were originally books would surprise you. Us marshall teddy daniels and his partner chuck are sent to an insane asylum on shutter island to investigate the disappearance or escape of a dangerous patient named rachel solando, who drowned her children in a lak. Teddy is on shutter island to find a missing mental patient.
Naehring accuses teddy of being a man of violence and compliments him on his defense mechanisms. I ts certainly not a horror film, nor is quite a thriller. In the book which is naturally going to be more descriptive than the movie there are several fact that contradict with each other. Martin scorsese wasnt kidding when he said that his neonoir psychological thriller shutter island would be twice as profitable because. Jan 27, 2019 the basis for the blockbuster motion picture directed by martin scorsese and starring leonardo dicaprio, shutter island by new york times bestselling author dennis lehane is a gripping and atmospheric psychological thriller where nothing is quite what it seems. The washington post raves, brilliantly conceived and. The story revolves around eli, a nomad in a postapocalyptic world, who is told by a voice to deliver his copy of a. Shutter islands ending explained david cox film the guardian. Differences between shutter island book vs movie page 1. Water, in teddys migraineinduced dreams, is a cruel instrument of death, and the heavy rains at the midpoint of lehanes novel cause considerable physical and psychic damage. It takes only one glimpse of shutter island to be filled with a sense of doom. If a reader can afford one book, shutter island is a terrific choice.
1558 1387 917 896 1261 1277 767 477 1133 645 1230 35 699 388 861 104 1168 848 1486 497 391 853 1190 763 574 1248 1069 1039 1140 1412 1329 86 1256 1017 991 1047 350